Eastport, NY Listings Dining Shopping Leisure Highest Rated Dining Trumpets On The Bay $$$ 107 reviews Party & Event Planning, New American (631) 325-2900 58 South Bay AveEastport, NY 11941 Eastport Luncheonette $ 66 reviews Diners (631) 325-8887 497A Montauk HwyEastport, NY 11941 Loco Lobster $ 23 reviews Seafood, Pizza, Sandwiches (631) 909-3737 223 Montauk HwyEast Moriches, NY 11940 Tacos Leales $ 5 reviews Tacos (631) 961-6088 491 Montauk HwyEastport, NY 11941 Triangle Pub $$ 100 reviews Pubs, American, Burgers (631) 325-1849 381 Old Montauk HwyEastport, NY 11941 Michelangelo Pizzeria & Restaurant $$ 87 reviews Pizza, Italian (631) 325-1314 11 Eastport Manor RdEastport, NY 11941 El Rodeo $$ 49 reviews Mexican (631) 909-2666 130 Montauk HwyUnit H G Love’s Kitchen image/svg+xml $ 1 reviews Caribbean, Food Trucks, Burgers (929) 679-7109 50 S Bay AveEastport, NY 11941 Citarelli's Market $ 24 reviews Delis, Italian (631) 325-0025 525 Montauk HwyEastport, NY 11941 Pete's Bagels $ 44 reviews Bagels, Breakfast & Brunch (631) 325-8410 587 Montauk HwyEastport, NY 11941 Eastport Plaza Delicatessen & Catering $ 13 reviews Delis, Breakfast & Brunch (631) 325-8846 13 Eastport-Manor RdEastport, NY 11941